May 7, 2025

Creating an advertising plan in 2025: A strategic guide for professional service firms

Bob Flavin · 9 minute read

Advertising shouldn’t feel like gambling.

Many law firms and small businesses see paid advertising as a necessary but stressful gamble. You might invest thousands—sometimes hundreds of thousands—into campaigns with the hope, not confidence, that they’ll pay off. The rapid changes in platforms, algorithms, and privacy rules have only made the advertising landscape feel more unpredictable.

Why does this happen? Because too many advertising plans are based on guesswork, legacy advice, or last year’s results, without accounting for the systemic changes that affect how ads actually perform. Let’s change that.

In this guide, we’ll build a smarter advertising plan for 2025, grounded in strategy, budget alignment, and system-level thinking. Whether you’re leading a law firm, managing a small business, or simply trying to understand how ads really work, this is for you.

Understanding the landscape: What’s changed (and what hasn’t)

The basics of advertising are still the same: show the right message to the right people at the right time. But the context around that principle has undergone a shift. The forces reshaping advertising today are systemic, not superficial. If you’re still running campaigns based on a checklist from 2019, you’re not just behind. You’re misaligned with how the game is played now.

Let’s unpack three of the most significant shifts:

Data privacy is now a front-and-center concern for consumers and platforms alike.

While the “death of third party cookies” might have been overblown, the broader trend is unmistakable. Individuals want more control over how their personal information is collected and used. Regulations like GDPR and CCPA have already shifted the landscape, and platforms are responding by limiting cross-site tracking, introducing consent tools, and offering privacy-first alternatives.

What does this mean for advertisers? It means you need to build your strategy around first-party data. Own your audience insights through your CRM, site analytics, intake forms, and direct interactions.

AI is everywhere.

Modern ad platforms have layered in machine learning at nearly every level: bidding, targeting, ad placement, creative rotation. That doesn’t mean they always get it right. Automated bidding tools like Google’s Smart Bidding or Performance Max campaigns can be powerful, but they’re not infallible.

Until recently, tools like Performance Max didn’t give you enough clarity or control to make them truly helpful. Even today, these systems require human oversight. Your job isn’t to micromanage every detail, but it is to monitor, test, and adapt.

Costs are up, and not by accident.

Google and Meta dominate their markets and are often investigated for antitrust behavior. Rising costs aren’t just a result of competition; they’re baked into the mechanics. Ad auctions prioritize spend, and automation often drives higher bids under the guise of efficiency. If you’re not actively managing your strategy, testing creative, refining segments, feeding quality signals, you’re not competing. You’re just feeding the machine.

This isn’t just technical noise. It’s the operating environment your advertising plan has to navigate. Treat these shifts like constraints in an engineering problem. When you understand the system, you can build a plan that works within it, not against it.

Start with objectives, not tactics

Too often, the planning process starts with a tactic: “We need to run Facebook ads.” But this is like deciding to buy a billboard without knowing who you’re trying to reach or what you’re trying to achieve. It’s not a strategy; it’s a reaction.

Instead, start by asking: what are we trying to accomplish? This isn’t about marketing jargon or abstract KPIs. It’s about defining the business result you need and reverse-engineering the steps to get there. Maybe it’s:

Increasing new client leads by 25%.
Driving 50 qualified attendees to a webinar.
Retargeting past visitors to convert 20% into consultations.

Once you define the outcome, then—and only then—do you choose the platform. And not just based on popularity or price. You evaluate platforms based on their alignment with your audience’s intent and behaviors. Search ads? Great for people already looking for help. Social? Better for building demand and staying top of mind.

This objective-first approach also protects your budget. If the goal is clear, so is the definition of success. That means you can evaluate performance based on impact, not just activity. Are you getting closer to your goal? If not, your strategy, not just the ad creative, needs to change.

Know your audience: Build real segments, not personas

One of the most common missteps in advertising strategy is thinking you know your audience—when really, you’re relying on stereotypes or outdated assumptions. Generic personas like “Budget-Conscious Bob” may make for catchy slides, but they rarely reflect the complexity of real-world behavior.

In 2025, audience targeting should start with evidence, not anecdotes. Your best segments aren’t imaginary composites, they’re based on real data. Here’s what that looks like:

People who visited your website in the last 30 days.
People actively searching for terms like “personal injury lawyer near me.”
People who submitted an intake form but didn’t schedule.
Past clients who haven’t engaged in 12+ months.

These are trackable, targetable groups. And they give you leverage, not just in ad delivery, but in messaging. Each segment has different motivations, objections, and readiness levels. A first-time visitor needs awareness and education. A past lead might just need a nudge.

This kind of segmentation is especially critical in regulated industries. Laws governing privacy, retargeting, and audience definition add another layer of complexity. But they also reward precision. The more accurate your segments, the less waste you incur—and the more ethical and compliant your campaigns become.

In short: stop guessing who your audience is. Start showing up where they actually are, with the message they actually need.

Choose the right channels for the right job

Every platform has strengths and limitations. In 2025, platforms are less defined by format (search, video, social) and more by how well they align with a specific type of user behavior and intent.

Start by mapping your audience’s journey: Are they actively searching? Browsing and discovering? Revisiting a decision? Then match that intent with the most appropriate platform. Here’s how to think about it:

Google Search ads: Best for high-intent users who are actively looking for a solution. If someone’s typing in “business litigation attorney Grand Rapids,” they’re ready. These leads can be expensive but valuable, especially if you’re tracking intake properly.
Meta (Facebook/Instagram): Better for demand generation and staying visible. These platforms excel at keeping your brand top of mind and nudging people back into action through remarketing. But don’t expect cold leads to convert on the first click.
YouTube and CTV: These are not direct-response channels; they’re brand-building and awareness drivers. Think of them as the modern TV spot, but smarter and more targeted.
LSAs (for law firms): Strong for lead generation, but you give up some control and privacy. To learn more about how Google’s terms and conditions changed for LSAs, read our recent article.
Display ads: Useful for remarketing, especially when layered with behavioral data. They’re weak for cold outreach unless paired with strong targeting and creative.

The takeaway: don’t pick a channel because it’s trendy or cheap. Pick it because it does a specific job in your larger system. A platform is a tool. Know what it’s good at, and what it’s not.

The key is understanding what each channel can and can’t do, and budgeting accordingly.

Build the funnel: Don’t rely on one campaign to do everything

In 2025, buyer journeys are longer, messier, and more nonlinear than ever. People don’t just click an ad and convert—not in legal services, not in healthcare, and not in most considered-purchase categories. They explore. They lurk. They bounce. Then they come back when they’re ready.

That’s why your ad plan needs to be structured like a funnel, not a billboard. Each campaign should do one job:

Awareness: Introduce your brand to people who have never heard of you. Focus on broad reach, storytelling, and values. Don’t expect conversions here—expect recognition and recall.
Consideration: Serve content that helps your audience evaluate you. This could be explainer videos, testimonials, or landing pages that answer key questions. The goal is trust-building, not hard-selling.
Conversion: Now you go in for the ask. These ads should have strong calls to action and minimal friction. Whether it’s a call, form fill, or chat, the goal is a clear next step—and a system that makes it easy to take.

This structure not only mirrors real human behavior, it gives you better data. If conversion rates drop, you can look at the right stage: Is awareness weak? Is the mid-funnel content irrelevant? Is the CTA buried? You don’t fix performance by tweaking a headline, you fix it by tuning the system.

Map each campaign to a funnel stage, and make sure you’re building toward something, not just broadcasting into the void. Then, measure each step. This helps you fix the right part of the system when performance drops.

Tie your budget to outcomes

Budgeting is where a lot of advertising plans fall apart. Some firms (and agencies) set their budget like this: pick a round number, spread it across channels, and hope it turns into results. But hope isn’t a plan.

If you’re serious about advertising, your budget should work backwards from your goals. That means tying dollars to cost per acquisition (CPA).

Start here:

What’s your target CPA ? (Let’s say $1,000 per new client.)
How many new clients do you want? (Maybe 40 this quarter.)
Multiply: 40 x $1,000 = $40,000.

That’s your working budget.

Next, pressure test it:

Have you hit that CPA before?
Do industry benchmarks support it?
Is your team equipped to handle 40 new clients or refer them out?

This kind of budgeting forces clarity. It makes you ask: Are we spending to grow, or just spending to spend? It also helps you spot inefficiencies faster—if your actual CPA spikes to $2,000, you know where to focus.

The best part? This method scales. Whether your budget is $2,000 or $200,000, the logic holds. Start with the outcome, define your efficiency, and build your system from there.

Track the right metrics (and ignore the vanity ones)

If you’ve ever sat through an ad report that bragged about a million impressions, you’ve probably felt the disconnect. Big numbers can feel impressive, but they often hide the truth. In 2025, platforms will flood you with surface-level data: reach, impressions, likes, video views. These can be vanity metrics. They make you feel like something’s happening, but they don’t prove that anything worked.

Here’s how to separate signal from noise:

Track conversions, not clicks. What matters is what people do after the ad, not how many saw it or clicked. Form fills, booked calls, and scheduled consultations are the metrics that actually tie to revenue.
Monitor cost per conversion. This tells you how efficiently your budget is working. If it’s rising, that’s a signal to review your audience, creative, or platform strategy.
Assess lead quality. This requires connecting your ad data to your CRM or intake notes. If your leads are all tire-kickers or spam, you’re not targeting correctly, even if your cost-per-lead looks low on paper.
Use click-through rate (CTR) diagnostically. It won’t tell you success, but it can tell you friction. A low CTR might mean your creative doesn’t connect, or that you’re reaching the wrong people.

Good reporting doesn’t just measure. It helps you make decisions. If your current setup only tells you what happened, but not why or what to fix, you don’t have reporting. You have a recap.

AI-powered dashboards like Clearboard can help you see the full picture. And make sure that picture actually maps to the outcomes your business cares about.

Creative still matters. A lot.

Targeting gets you in front of the right people. Creative determines what happens next.

In 2025, many ad platforms use machine learning to optimize delivery, but they can’t compensate for unclear, unconvincing, or lazy creative. The best targeting in the world won’t save an ad that doesn’t resonate. You’re not just competing against other firms, you’re competing against everything else in your audience’s feed.

What separates effective creative from the noise?

Clarity: The viewer should understand in two seconds what you do and why it matters.
Relevance: Speak to the problem your audience is actually trying to solve—not what you want to talk about.
Actionability: Every ad should have a job. Make the next step obvious and frictionless.

But that’s just the baseline. To improve, you need to test. A/B test headlines, visuals, calls to action, and landing page variants. Small tweaks can lead to major differences in performance. And the best campaigns often win not with the first idea, but with the fifth iteration.

Great creative doesn’t just look good. It works hard. It communicates value, earns trust, and moves people. In a crowded, noisy landscape, that’s not just a nice-to-have, it’s the edge.

Build feedback loops

Advertising isn’t a one-and-done task. It’s a system. To make that system work, you need real feedback. That means closing the loop between your marketing, intake, sales, and leadership functions.

Ask these questions regularly:

Are intake teams reporting low-quality leads? That might mean your targeting is too broad or your message is attracting the wrong audience.
Are specific ads driving higher conversion rates or better-qualified leads? Double down on what works.
Are you over-relying on one channel or tactic? Look at channel performance over time and rebalance.

This isn’t just about optimization, it’s about alignment. When your marketing team understands what the intake team is hearing, and your leadership team sees how ad performance maps to business growth, your entire system improves.

That’s also where Clearboard, LaFleur’s analytics platform, can make a difference. It doesn’t just surface metrics; it surfaces insights. You can trace campaigns to revenue, understand lead quality across channels, and pinpoint which parts of your system are driving results versus draining resources. It turns data into feedback, and feedback into smarter decisions,

When to call in help

Even the most capable internal teams hit limits of time, expertise, or perspective. Building a high-performing advertising system requires more than just hitting “boost” on a post. It requires deep strategic thinking, technical setup, data integration, creative oversight, and ongoing optimization.

If your team is stretched thin, unsure where to focus, or stuck in analysis paralysis, it’s time to bring in support. Not just a freelancer to make ads, but a partner who can:

Build an advertising strategy that ties directly to your business goals.
Set up clear attribution so you know what’s working—and what’s not.
Analyze and optimize campaigns continuously, not just at the end of the month.
Translate your data into next steps, not just dashboards.

And ideally? Someone who will hold themselves accountable to outcomes, not just impressions and clicks. That’s the kind of partner we aim to be at LaFleur. We don’t just run ads. We help professional service firms build smarter, more resilient systems that convert attention into action—and action into impact.

You deserve an advertising plan that works

Advertising doesn’t have to be mysterious, chaotic, or wasteful. With the right strategy, systems, and partners in place, it can become a growth engine you actually understand and control.

That’s what we build at LaFleur. We help law firms and professional service providers craft advertising strategies rooted in real business goals. We connect your campaigns to your intake pipeline. We implement tracking that tells the truth. And with Clearboard, our analytics platform, we turn your marketing performance into something you can see, explain, and act on.

If your current advertising feels like a black box—or worse, a money pit—we’re ready to help you fix it. Schedule a consultation with LaFleur today. Let’s build something that works.

Let’s talk